The Accidental Discovery of a Sears Custom Home

Beginning in 1930, Sears began heavily promoting their custom home design and construction services. Rather than using the Sears standard house plans, the customer could create a custom plan. According to the Modern Homes catalog: "If you have been unable to select a design from our Modern Home Catalog that meets your requirements, you should not fail to take advantage of this special plan service, our experienced organization and low prices on high quality material."

These custom Sears houses are nearly impossible to identify since they are one-of-a-kind.

I recently saw a house in Glenview that vaguely resembled a custom Sears house I had seen featured in the 1938 Modern Homes catalog.

The actual house was built in Merchantville, NJ.

1044 Golfview Road, Glenview. The houses really aren't that similar (and the Glenview house is much larger), but I wondered if the same architect designed both. To me, this house had the "Sears look".

  

Intrigued, I searched the Chicago Tribune archives for the address. I found a 1936 article that stated the owner of the house was General William H. Rose. 

Ka-ching! 

Rose was the General Supervisor of the Sears Modern Homes Department. I knew this house was a Sears custom house; now I just needed some proof.

Fortunately, the current homeowner had the scoop. She already knew that the house was built by Sears. And she had a copy of the original blueprints!

The blueprints clearly state that the client was General and Mrs. W.H. Rose, and that the plans were from the Home Construction Division of Sears, Roebuck & Co. The date is 11/13/1933. Photo courtesy of Jurdis Walton.

On the blueprints, there is a "Drawn By" field and the initials "BTL". I believe these initials stand for B.T. Lourim, an architect who was working for Sears at the time.

I wonder how many people already know their houses are Sears houses but have never mentioned it.

East side of the General W.H. Rose house. Photo courtesy of Nina Yoo.

West side of the house.

This house was built in 1934, and originally sat on 2.25 acres.

The house is largely original. According to the homeowner, only the kitchen was expanded and a bathroom added to one of the bedrooms.

The interior walls are made of plywood. This was not typical of Sears houses, although plywood was gaining popularity in the 1930's so maybe the Roses wanted to jump on that trend.

William H. Rose retired from the Army in 1919 with rank of Brigadier General. He was one of the engineers who worked on the Panama Canal, and a couple of his children were born in Panama.

General Robert E. Wood, who led Sears, Roebuck for many years, served with Rose in World War I. Wood joined Sears in 1924 and Rose joined sometime after. By 1930 Rose was working for Sears and his family was living in Chicago.

The Roses moved to Bradenton, Florida in 1940 and General Rose became the special assistant to the Deputy Chief of Engineers, U.S. Army.

By 1943, Edward P. Byrnes and his family were living the house. He was the owner of a trucking business--North Shore and Central Illinois Freight. He also was a member of the Glenview village board in the mid-1960's. Mrs. Byrnes served as a trustee for the Glenview Public Library.

The current homeowners bought the house in 1986 from the Byrnes family. 

I Love this Catalog Cover

Researcher Rachel Shoemaker recently posted this cover of the Gordon-Van Tine Company's Book of Homes from 1935.

Photo is copyright 2013 Rachel Shoemaker and can not be used or reproduced without permission.

This is my favorite cover of all the house catalogs I've seen to date. It sends a powerful message about Gordon-Van Tine homes without even showing the home.

It communicates to the reader the sense of security that home ownership provides. The family is enjoying life and creating memories with the house as the backdrop. Note that the father is not in the photo... he is the reader and Gordon-Van Tine's target customer.

The hairstyles, the shoes, the skates, the colors... love the whole thing.  It's a glimpse into a simpler, more relaxed era. 

The Monticello from Standard Homes Company

5656 N. Newark, Chicago

Photo from Realtor site.

Here is a gorgeous plan book house in Norwood Park. It is the Monticello model from the Standard Homes Company. (The Standard Homes Company still sells house plans today.) 

The Monticello is a Colonial Revival with just over 1,900 square feet, a huge reception hall, and three large bedrooms. The house in Norwood Park is a reverse plan.

According to the Standard Homes plan book, "If those who occupy homes like The Monticello are not happy it is because they have violated some natural law, or are not conscious of the fact that happiness is a condition of the mind and comes as the result of the mastery of one's moods. It is not a thing to be purchased at a price, but rather a fact to be recognized or accepted, regardless." I'm not sure I understand all that, but whatever.

The architect of the Monticello was Lyman J. Allison, a noted bungalow architect in Chicago. 

The Monticello on Newark was built in summer of 1928. The original owner was B. McMillan.

Sears Tests the Market for Prefabricated Housing in the Chicago Suburbs

Tough Times for the Sears Modern Homes Department
During the Great Depression, business conditions deteriorated and residential building had slowed to a trickle. Sales of Sears kit houses fell precipitously in 1931. 

In 1932, Sears rolled out a “lock and key” price for complete homes, including all materials and labor (but not the land). For 22 of their standard plans, the prices for the complete homes ranged from $3,800 to $12,000, which was beyond the comfort level of most consumers. The Modern Homes Department suffered "terrific losses" in 1932. Not only were sales of houses down, but Sears also acquired the titles on 396 properties through foreclosures or quit-claim deeds. They had foreclosure losses over $1.5M just in the first part of 1932.

General William H. Rose, the General Supervisor of the Modern Homes Department, recommended that Sears continue selling homes through 1933, but if the company did not meet minimum sales volume that the business be liquidated. 

Sears did not meet their sales or profitability goals for 1933, and the Sears Modern Homes Department officially closed. Sears liquidated $11M in mortgages in 1934, according to the Sears, Roebuck annual report. In 1935 the Modern Homes Department reopened with very limited operations. 

By 1935, Sears understood that their pre-cut house kits were too expensive for most Americans. Sears wanted to sell more houses to people earning between $2,000 and $2,500 per year, the lower bracket of the “white collar” class.

The “Experiment” with General Houses, Inc.
In August 1935, there was a meeting among four Sears vice-presidents, General Rose, and L.R. Walker (the Supervisor of the Modern Homes Department)  to determine how best to resuscitate the Modern Homes business. They presented their recommendation to General Robert E. Wood, who was the President of Sears, Roebuck.

The recommendation was for Sears to spend $15,000 to test the idea of selling prefabricated (not pre-cut) houses. Walker believed that General Houses, Inc., based in Chicago, had the best prefabricated house models. General Houses stated they could build a four-room house with a garage for $2500 and a five-room house with a garage for $3500, assuming they had sufficient volume.

The $15,000 would be used to construct a General Houses model in a Chicago suburb and market it for three months. Sears felt this $15,000 “experiment” would serve four purposes: 

• Test the public reaction to a prefabricated house and “feel the pulse of the market”.
• Determine whether Sears could sell enough houses to make the venture financially viable.
• Determine the actual cost of materials and the cost of construction.
• Gauge the responses of the labor unions.

Importantly, Wood said he would "veto any plan for resuming the Modern Homes operations if we have to guarantee the mortgages." Sears would not be doing any financing, and planned to reach agreements with certain lenders who would offer mortgages to customers for up to $3,000.

More about General Houses
General Houses, Inc. designed and constructed prefabricated steel housing.  Architect Howard T. Fisher formed the company in 1932. The company used pressed-steel panels for walls, roofs, and floors, set on a concrete foundation. After the foundation was set, a team could put a house together in about two weeks. 

General Houses received nationwide publicity in 1933. They displayed a pressed steel cottage at the 1933 Chicago World's Fair that attracted thousands of visitors.

The house by General Houses at the 1933 Chicago World's Fair. The house was later moved to Riverside after the Fair.

By August 1935, General Houses had sold only seven of the all steel houses in the Chicago area. They were very modern and very expensive, and their customers were typically Chicago notables such as the CEO of the Wurlitzer Grand Piano Company and Adlai E. Stevenson (grandson of the former Vice-President of the United States).

The chairman of the board of General Houses, Edmund Lindop from Oak Park, brokered the partnership with Sears.

Four Houses, Not One
Although the recommendation from the August 1935 executive meeting was to build one General Houses model as a test, Sears ended up paying for four houses to be built. The model homes opened in May 1936. 

Two houses were in Lombard on Roosevelt Road and Meyers Road (where a CVS Pharmacy stands today), one in Highland Park at 3079 Greenwood (which was torn down for a McMansion) , and one in Tinley Park at 17659 S. Oak Park Avenue (which still stands today).

3079 Greenwood, Highland Park. This was the larger model which was offered for sale at $5964. The same larger model was also constructed in Lombard. Photo courtesy of the Herbert Hoover Presidential Library.

Likely based on feedback from Sears, General Houses changed their construction approach for the four models. They used a steel framing system with exterior siding panels of asbestos, cement board and insulation. They used fir plywood for interior walls. Floors were concrete but could be covered with wood or linoleum for extra charge. The flat roof was surfaced in steel. This approach was much less expensive than the all steel fabrication.

17659 S. Oak Park Avenue, Tinley Park. This was the smaller model which was offered for sale at $4910. The same smaller model was also constructed in Lombard. Photo courtesy of Amin Ahmad.

The Tinley Park house is now occupied by the Printer's Quill print shop. It initially served as a residence, and then was later converted to a physician’s office. 

The house has been drastically changed, with a brick masonry façade and a second floor added to the building. The brick exterior threw me—I was certain the original house was torn down. However, Sears house researcher Mark Hardin was confident that the Printer’s Quill shop is, in fact, the house built in 1936. And he was correct!

Sometime after the Sears executive team meeting in August 1935, Sears changed its strategy. The new plan was for General Houses to supply all the building materials, arrange for the construction through their dealer network, and sell the houses. Sears hoped to sell the new homeowners furnishings and other house fixtures. Sears executives thought that even if they were not going to continue selling houses to their customers, they would still profit if more Americans could own homes because low-cost prefabricated housing was readily available. Through the joint advertising, both firms hoped to push sales.

Joint advertising for Sears and General Houses.

The interior of one of the houses. All modern furnishings and interior decoration were provided by Sears. Photo courtesy of the Herbert Hoover Presidential Library.

Thousands of people would tour the model houses, but there were few buyers.  In the month after the models were built, General Houses reported that they had received $109,000 in orders (about 18 houses). Sears did manage to sell all four of the model houses.  Sears declined to continue the partnership with General Houses after the prefabrication “experiment”.

According to a Business Week article from 1939: "Sears 1936 tie-up with General Houses, Inc. ended unhappily, with dissatisfaction over too close a relation between exterior and interior temperatures in the prefabricated structures." 

The Aftermath
Sears continued to sell pre-cut houses until 1942. In the later years, they began to use steel columns as part of the foundation. 

In 1946, Sears took another plunge into prefabricated housing. They sold a "ready-to erect" house-- partially pre-cut, partially prefabricated--under the name Homart Homes.  

General Houses went on alone and continued to sell the less expensive steel framed/asbestos siding models, but by September 1936 they had sold only 45. Seven were in Lake Forest (on Everett Road and Highland Avenue), one in Downers Grove, one in Highland Park, and one in Libertyville. The rest were likely built outside the Chicago area. (If you know where any of these houses are, please email me!)

Around 1942, General Houses gave up on steel and switched to wood frame construction. The steel houses were not economical to produce. Additionally, the houses were often not able to meet local building codes, and banks were reluctant to finance flat-roofed houses. General Houses built less than 150 houses nationwide. Today, most of the cutting-edge steel and steel-framed houses that General Houses built have been demolished.